Minutes of the Steering Board Meeting, 19 September 2007
K. Amako, J. Apostolakis, M. Asai, G. Cosmo, G. Folger, A. Heikkinen,
V. Ivantchenko, I. McLaren, J. Perl, T. Sasaki, D. Wright, H. Yoshida
Minutes taken by D. Wright. Further editing: J. Apostolakis
Version 0.3, of 19 October 2007, 17:20 UTC
Minutes of previous meeting
Release 9.1 - December 2007
- Features planned/expected, and potentially at risk (or late)
- Parallel navigation: fixes and improvements ongoing. Uncertain whether it can be default;
- The ABLA module is not yet ready and is potentially at risk of being late.
- Physics list per region not ready
- GUI packages and modules using wxPython or Pythonized wxWidgets
- GUI toolkit (?-to be clarified)
- Known issues
- Bertini cascade: lack of Coulomb barrier is becoming a risk. Not sure if
first version of charge exchange will be ready.
- New INCL code needs significant testing before it is released. A dedicated system test must be developed for it.
- Requirements on iteration snapshot (?) need to be investigated
- Features whose status was not known:
- Completion of Root I/O object persistency
- First version of charge exchange (related to Bertini cascade ?)
- New capabilities, requests:
- Strong request from users for ICRU 73. This is being looked at. Additional resources needed for early delivery.
- The release date of December 14 has been been confirmed.
Geant4 review follow-up
- Agreed to have the report of the Geant4 review 2007 linked to the collaboration web page, if Oversight Board proposes.
- Assessing and acting on the review recommendations will require concentrated effort and a clear, comprehensive strategy:
- Agreed to establish a small team which will assess the report and recommend actions. Makoto volunteered to contribute in a leading capacity.
- Action item for Makoto: develop full mandate for team.
Report from the Oversight Board Meeting
- Took place in Lyon on June 12th
- Items discussed:
- G4 review recommendations
- manpower and resources: in order to seek more resources some members requested a development plan, potentially in the form of a
Gant chart spanning high-level milestones over the next years.
- Proposed to hold a delta review within about one year, potentially July 2008.
Assessing Geant4 risks
- Age of parts of Geant4 system/code is now an issue. Key interfaces and designs have remained unchanged since 1996-1997. Many classes' implementations have been revised significantly, and many new large classes have created, resulting in some code which is harder to understand and maintain.
- Review in 2008 should examine the architecture, concentrating on the design of key interfaces. The addition of new functionality utilising existing interfaces (cuts per region, biasing/scoring, parallel navigation) has complicated the overall design and should be taken into account in the assessment.
- The implementation of many classes is aging. Concentrated work to identify important classes 'at risk', and review their code is significant priority for 2008 and 2009.
- Action item for Makoto: reinvigorate architecture group and create a proposal for the first 'target' issues by 31 January 2008.
Addressing some issues raised during workshop
- Problems with existing installation used especially for testing (and also to demonstrate in examples) and new user requirements for analysis use and installation for
- Proposal to include in Geant4 native, simple (1D, 2D), ascii output only
- Agreed to include simple native histogramming outputing to text, if requirements and constraints can be met.
- Makoto and Pete proposed to contribute.
- Proposal for physics vector using spline interpolation
Reports from WG
- Hadronics Working Group
- Leadership re-organization: changed from two co-coordinators to a coordinator and
deputy. For the next two years Dennis will be coordinator and Gunter deputy
- Action item for Dennis: inform group members of result and solicit comments from
group members who could not be present at discussion of leadership change and
- Vladimir Ivantchenko proposed installing cuts for recoiling nuclei in hadronic
- Alain Boudard, Jose Manuel Quesada-Molina and Pekka Kaitaniemi (student member)
were approved for collaboration membership
Additional Resources Needed
- Ian McLaren is retiring in April 2008. He is not only System Testing coordinator but also
the person who is undertaking the system integration testing for Geant4. He has been in
this position for the past two years.
- Replacement of his effort and expertise is required. This issued should be raised to
the Oversight Board.
1. Geant4 Associates
- In 0.5 to 1.5 years, several Geant4 members will retire. In order to create an
official channel for their continued participation, John Allison, Hajimi Yoshida,
Michel Maire and Katsuya Amako propose to organize a new group called
Geant4 Associates. It will be a non-profit organization designed to support